UPC_CFI_329/2024; UPC_CFI_728/2024 – Ericsson v Asus
- Court
- Local Division Milan
- Date
- Sector
- Electronics/SEP
- Decision Type
- PROCEDURAL
Expert Commentary
SEP case Facts 1. This case concerns the infringement and revocation of two patents. 2. The parties made requests on 31 August 2026 and 2 September 2026 with respect to the oral argument. The Presiding Judge/Judge-Rapporteur (“JR”) The Judge gives guidance for the oral hearing of 24 and 25 September 2026. Comment 1. This decision is published only now. This raises the question why so late? 2. It is unclear which patents it relates to. 3. It is also unclear who the other members of the panel are. 4. Why does the JR issue this decision on 21 September (3 days before the hearing) while the parties requests date of 31 August and 2 September? 5. The JR announces that at the start of the hearing “The panel will give the parties more specific guidance”. Parties get 10-15 minutes to organize the oral submission accordingly. Assuming that this means that the Court will state what its provisional opinion is with respect to certain arguments, then 10-15 minutes is very short and deviates from the 30-45 minutes we see elsewhere. 6. We now have to see if a decision will be rendered in 6 weeks (6 November is six weeks), which is reported right away.
Full Decision Text
Milan Local Division UPC CFI no. 318/2024, no. 730/2024 Order issued on 21.9.2026 CLAIMANT TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON 21 Torshamnsgatan, Kista, 164 83 Stockholm, Sweden represented by Wim Maas and David Mulder, at Taylor Wessing N.V., Parnassusweg 803-805a, 1082 LZ - Amsterdam, The Netherlands, and Faziel Abdul, at Taylor Wessing N.V., Kennedyplein 201, 5611 ZT - Eindhoven, The Netherlands DEFENDANTS 1) ASUSTEK COMPUTER INC. 1 F No. 15 Lide Rd Beitou Dist, Tapei City 11259, Taiwan 2) ARVATO NETHERLANDS B.V. Brem 1, 6598 MH Heijen, The Netherlands represented by Alexander Wiese and Eva Geschke, at Wildanger Kehrwald Graf v. Schwerin & Partner mbB Rechtsanwälte, Couvenstraße 8, 40211 - Düsseldorf, Germany Niccolò Ferretti, at Nunziante Magrone Studio Legale Associato, Foro Buonaparte n. 70, 20121 - Milano, Italy Rudolf Reichold and Thomas Hell, at Patentanwaltsgesellschaft mbH, Flüggenstraße 13, 80639 München, Germany DECIDING JUDGE judge-rapporteur Alima Zana LANGUAGE OF PROCEEDINGS English SUBJECT MATTER OF THE ORDER Guidance for the oral hearing ORDER Having regard to the parties’ applications lodged on 31 August 2026 by the claimant and on 2 September 2026 by the defendants, the judge-rapporteur gives the following directions for the conduct of the oral hearings on 24 and 25 September 2026, in accordance with the general directions set out in the order of 25 May 2026 pursuant to R. 105.5 RoP. The first day of the oral hearing shall be organised as follows: - a brief joint introduction addressing both patents: 10–15 minutes per side; - EP ’342: up to 1 hour each per side (claimant and defendants respectively), followed by 15 minutes per side for replies; - EP ’673: up to 1 hour each per side (claimant and defendants respectively), followed by 15 minutes per side for replies. At the beginning of the oral hearing, the Panel will give the parties more specific guidance on the issues that it considers most relevant for discussion. A short adjournment of 10–15 minutes will then be granted to allow each legal team to organise its oral submissions accordingly. The second day of the oral hearing shall be devoted entirely to the FRAND defence and remedies and shall be organised as follows: - up to 1 hour and 30 minutes per side per (claimant and defendants respectively), followed by 45 minutes each for replies. In this day the entire discussion shall be subject to the confidentiality regime. Accordingly, attendance in the courtroom and remote access shall be permitted only to those persons authorised by the Court pursuant to the orders previously issued in the course of these proceedings. The Panel may put questions to the parties and seek clarification at any time. The parties may use slides to support their oral submissions, provided that the slides contain no new arguments and refer exclusively to material already included and developed in the written pleadings. The parties shall exchange their respective slides by email, outside the CMS, no later than 13:00 on 23 September 2026, copying the clerks of the sub-registry at contact_milan.loc@unifiedpatentcourt.org. Milan, 21 September 2026. Alima Zana
Key Holdings
- The Judge-Rapporteur/Presiding Judge provides procedural guidance for the conduct of the upcoming oral hearing concerning the infringement and revocation of two patents.
- The panel will provide more specific guidance to the parties at the start of the oral hearing, with parties granted 10 to 15 minutes to organize their oral submissions accordingly.
Tags
- SEP case
- Oral hearing guidance
- Time allocation
- Judge-Rapporteur order